After Appeal, Lincoln Overturns Denial of LTD benefits for Trucking Supervisor
Our client, Mr. D, formerly worked as a Trucking Supervisor for a large steel distribution center. For many years Mr. D suffered from chronic debilitating effects of multiple physical conditions and ailments, including severe degenerative osteoarthritis and cervical spine multilevel degenerative disc disease, which left him with debilitating physical impairments. Mr. D was unwilling to give up his career and worked as long as he possibly could. As a result of his serious medical conditions and associated restrictions and limitations, Mr. D was forced to stop working in June 2016 and apply for disability benefits under his company’s Short and then Long Term Disability (LTD) Policies, both of which were administered and funded by Lincoln.
Lincoln found Mr. Dougherty to be totally disabled and approved his STD claim through the 13 week maximum benefit period which ended in September 2016. With the expiration of the STD benefits Mr. D’s claim was submitted for continued payment under Lincoln’s LTD Policy, with the same definition of disability. After paying his LTD benefit for 21 months Lincoln terminated benefits because claiming Mr. D could now perform his prior “heavy” occupation. Mr. Dougherty filed a timely appeal that was unsuccessful. Following a successful second level appeal, benefits were extended only for the balance of the own occupation period to September 2018 as Lincoln determined that Mr. D could perform other gainful occupations. After receiving the denial, Mr. D contacted Dell Disability Lawyers and discussed his case with Attorney Jay Symonds, who identified several significant issues in Lincoln’s denial letter and in the evidence it relied on and agreed to prepare and submit Mr. D’s ERISA appeal with the assistance of his appeal team.
The Appeal
The appeal addressed all of Lincoln’s short-comings and reasons for denial. First, the appeal detailed the results of a February 2020 FCE attended by Mr. D specifically for his appeal. The FCE objectively quantified his maximum physical functional capacity. With regard to sitting, standing and walking the FCE confirmed, among other restrictions, Mr. D had the ability to sit for 40 minute intervals, stand for 30 minute intervals and walk for 10 minutes intervals. Based on the findings in the FCE Mr. D would be unable to perform work in the sedentary physical demand level due to his inability to sit for 2 hours at any one time, stand and/or walk up to 2 hours, work an 8 hour workday, nor repetitively use his lower and upper extremities. The FCE findings were then reviewed and adopted by Mr. D’s primary care physician.
The Appeal Challenges Lincoln’s Medical Consultant
Next the appeal addressed the purported opinions of Lincoln’s medical consultant. More specifically, the consultant’s opinion relied, in part, on his belief that Mr. D could perform modified occupations, which was clearly outside the scope of his role as a medical records reviewer. Whether an occupation is available to be performed on a modified basis and whether an employer is willing to modify a particular occupation to accommodate employees is for a Vocational Consultant to determine, not a medical consultant. What’s more, the consultant was not board certified in a specialty relevant to Mr. D’s complex medical conditions (e.g., an Orthopedist) but rather as a physical medicine and rehabilitation physician, did not physically examine Mr. D prior to rendering his opinions and his conclusions were contradicted by the objective finding throughout Mr. D’s medical records.
And finally, the appeal addressed Lincoln’s failure to meaningfully review and consider Mr. D’s Social Security Disability Award, which Courts have repeatedly found instructive when determining whether a carrier conducted an unreasonable investigation. More specifically, the appeal argued that Lincoln’s conduct raised serious questions about whether its denial was the product of a principled and deliberative reasoning process or Lincoln’s financial conflict of interest due to its role as both the funding source and decision maker.
A Swift Decision by Lincoln
Just 6 weeks after filing his appeal, and after reviewing hundreds of pages of exhibits and medical records, Lincoln overturned its decision to terminate benefits, paid full LTD back benefits and reinstated Mr. D’s LTD benefits. Attorney Symonds continues to represent our client to best ensure that Lincoln will not terminate his benefits again. Feel free to call our disability attorneys for a free consultation regarding any matter relevant to your disability claim.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Submit a Strong Lincoln Financial Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Lincoln Financial appeal.
Sue Lincoln Financial
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Lincoln Financial.
Get Your Lincoln Financial Disability Application Approved
Prevent a Lincoln Financial Disability Benefit Denial
Negotiate a Lincoln Financial Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Policy Holder Rating
Lincoln Financial made my life a living hell
Reply
Lincoln Financials wants to claw back my money
Reply
This is the second time I've been shorted in my check
Lincoln Financial denied my STD claim because one doctor didn't send them my medical information.
Reply
Lincoln cancelled my benefits because my doctor's notes were handwritten
Reply
Lincoln denied my disability claim even though Dr said I couldn't work
Reply
Lincoln doesn't think renal failute and 4 dyalisis treatments per day are enough to be. Disabled
Reply
They promised me min 10% of my salary and max 60%. I got 6%
Reply
Q: If I return to work only part time and decide I can't continue, will Lincoln Financial base my income on when I worked part time or full time?
Q: Does Lincoln Financial apply offsets to all claimants equitably?
Q: Does payback to Lincoln Financial, once approved for SSDI, include the first year?
Q: Is LF's doctor, who never spoke with me or evaluated me, allowed to clear me for work?
Q: Can LF discontinue my mental health benefits after 24 months?
Q: Can Lincoln Financial deny a total disability claim approved by a federal judge? Can I get a lump sum payout instead of fighting with them for the next 9 years?
Q: Do I have to tell Lincoln Financial that I was denied for SSDI?
Q: What do I do if LF denied my claim because depression is "mild, not severe"?
Has Lincoln Contacted You About Your Liberty Disability Claim?
Is Lincoln Relying on MDGuidelines to Review Disability Appeals?
Lincoln Financial to Buy Liberty Life - Does This Affect My Disability Claim?
What Can A Claimant Expect With A Lincoln Financial Group Disability Claim?
Do You Know The Job Requirements To Be A Lincoln Financial Disability Claim Specialist?
Disability Denial Reason #1 – Paper Review & IME
How to Apply for Reliance Standard Disability Benefits & Top 5 Reasons for a Claim Denial
Applying for Standard Disability Benefits? Top 5 Claim Denial Reasons
Lincoln Approves Long Term Disability Benefits After Four Year Fight
Lincoln National LTD Denial for Pre-Existing Condition Reversed on Appeal
Lincoln overturned its previous denial of LTD benefits for Escalation Engineer
After Appeal, Lincoln Overturns Denial of LTD benefits for Trucking Supervisor
Dell Disability Lawyers Wins Short Term Disability Appeal Against Lincoln
Lincoln National Life Insurance Company overturned previous denial of long term disability benefits for Wyoming Professor
Dell Disability Lawyers Administrative Appeal for Cafeteria Manager Forces Lincoln to Re-Approve Disability Claim
Computer Programmer is back on claim receiving LTD Benefits after Attorney proves to Lincoln it acted wrongly
Reviews from Our Clients






