Cigna Exposes Disability Plan Administrator To $9,900 ERISA Penalty For Failure To Produce Plan Documents
The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, better known as ERISA, the federal law which governs most employer provided insurance benefit plans (ie. group disability, health, life, etc.), is not known for its favorable treatment of claimants seeking recourse and recovery of monetary damages through the federal courts. However, there can be penalties for an insurance company’s or plan administrator’s wrongful actions which violate ERISA regulations.
In most ERISA lawsuits the claimant has exhausted their insurance plan’s administrative remedies and is pursuing the recovery of benefits in federal court. The recovery of past due insurance benefits are generally the only recovery allowed by the courts. In some instances, the federal court will award the claimant seeking benefits an award of attorney fees, however, such an award is in the court’s discretion, and not always awarded.
Penalties Can Be Imposed When The Plan Administrator Fails To Timely Provide Documents Requested By The Claimant
In some cases the claimant, in conjunction with their claim for benefits, is also pursuing a claim for ERISA statutory damages predicated on the plan administrator’s failure to provide documents expressly relied upon by the plan administrator in making its claim determination. Prior to commencing any sort of action under ERISA for recovery of statutory damages for failure to provide documentation, the claimant must have first expressly requested the specific documentation.
The documentation could be anything ranging from the master plan/policy, a report from the insurance companies medical consultant, or in some instances even communications between the claims personnel and the plan administrator’s in-house attorneys. The penalties for failure on the part of the plan administrator to timely release documentation to the claimant can range from $1.00 to $110 a day for every day that the plan administrator fails to comply with the claimant’s request, following the expiration of 30 day deadline.
No case serves as a better example of the penalties imposed on a plan administrator that fails to comply with a request for documents than Mondry v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company, a case which appeared before the 7th Circuit Court of Appeal twice on distinct issues.
Sharon Mondry worked for American Family Mutual Insurance Company (“American”) until September 2003. American self-funded its employee health plan, but contracted with CIGNA to act as its health plan’s third-party claims administrator. This meant that CIGNA would handle any and all benefit claims against the Plan, and American would pay the benefits if CIGNA determined there was compensable claim. Ms. Mondry’s son Zev, whom she had enrolled as a Plan beneficiary, required speech therapy so Ms. Mondry enrolled her son in a speech therapy center that submitted invoices to the CIGNA seeking reimbursement for the services it provided to Zev.
CIGNA declined the claim for reimbursement, stating that Zev’s speech therapy was not medically necessary nor covered under the terms of the Plan. As required under the Plan, Ms. Mondry appealed the denial of benefits directly with CIGNA. CIGNA denied Mondry’s first appeal, and in the denial letter cited two documents in its reasoning. CIGNA cited its Benefit Interpretation Resource Tool for Speech Therapy (“BIRT”), and its Clinical Resource Tool for Speech (“CRT”). However, both documents were inconsistent with the terms of the actual Plan. Ms. Mondry sought the assistance of legal counsel to submit her second appeal with CIGNA. Upon being retained, and seeing that CIGNA had referenced the BIRT AND CRT, Ms. Mondry’s legal counsel wrote a letter to CIGNA and American Family requesting the BIRT AND CRT. After a combined total of 309 (94 to produce the BIRT and 215 to produce the CRT) days, American Family and CIGNA produced the documents requested by Ms. Mondry’s legal counsel. Eventually (2 years after the claim was initiated), and only after Ms. Mondry’s legal counsel was able to succeed in obtaining the BIRT and CRT, did CIGNA realize its error and agree to pay all of Ms. Mondry’s out of pocket costs related to Zev’s speech therapy.
Court Orders Disability Plan Administrator to Pay $9,900 in statutory Penalties to Claimant
Ms. Mondry, through her legal counsel, sued American Family and CIGNA in federal court, pursuant to ERISA, for their failures to timely provide her with the BIRT and CRT following her request, and for violating their fiduciary duties to her as a Plan participant by withholding key documents from her. The 7th Circuit Court of Appeal determined that CIGNA’s express reliance on the BIRT and CRT effectively rendered the two internal documents “Plan Documents” that were subject to timely production pursuant to ERISA. In addition, the Court held that even though CIGNA had sole possession of the BIRT and CRT, the liability for the failure to produce such documents fell upon American Family alone. The Court was also not convinced that it was beyond American Family’s power to obtain access to the BIRT and CRT. The Court separately concluded that American Family was also liable for the lost time value of money Ms. Mondry was forced to expend for Zev’s speech therapy until she finally obtained copies of the CRT and BIRT and was able to prevail in her appeal with CIGNA. Ms. Mondry was awarded $9,270 ($30 per day for 309 days) in damages from American Family, due to CIGNA failure to produce the plan documents, and was awarded $630 in stipulated damages for breach of fiduciary duty, representing the time value of the money Ms. Mondry was forced to expend for Zev’s speech therapy, while she waited for CIGNA to reverse its decision.
Although ERISA can often be unkind to claimants seeking disability and other insurance benefits, Mondry is an example of how employers/plan administrators can be held to task for the failures of their third-party administrators to timely produce requested plan documents, as CIGNA was in this case. Although the monetary damages were certainly no windfall for Ms. Mondry, it can be safely assumed that American Family and CIGNA expended a considerable sum in defending themselves, and there is no question that their ignorance and/or misplaced beliefs concerning the plan documents in question proved to be a cost prohibitive risk not worth taking.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Disability Benefit Denial Options
Submit a Strong Cigna Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Cigna appeal.
Sue Cigna
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Cigna.
Protect Your Benefits
Get Your Cigna Disability Application Approved
We help claimants throughout the entire application process.
Prevent a Cigna Disability Benefit Denial
We manage every aspect of your disability claim following claim approval.
Negotiate a Cigna Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Cigna Reviews
(103)
Policy Holder Rating
5
0%
4
0%
3
0%
2
53%
1
45%
Timely Payments
1.9out of 5
Handling Claim
2.0out of 5
Customer Service
2.0out of 5
Dependable
1.9out of 5
Value
1.9out of 5
Showing 8 of 103 Reviews
Cigna
Payment delays!
I have a Long term disability claim with Cigna. Approval process did not take too long and they did start my LTD just a few days after my STD ended. First check was mailed... read more >
Cigna
Cigna (NYL) denied my claim
I’ve been an RN for 31 years. I lost 6 family members (3 of those to cancer) in 9 months and suffered a breakdown, I just couldn’t watch people die anymore. Cigna (NYL... read more >
Cigna
Hold up on payments!!!
I have had 3 people on my case since July 2021! This last person Amanda S drag her feet on my claims and payments. I literally have to go to my mom for help! When I contac... read more >
Cigna
Paid Family Leave
I haven’t received a single check while on paid family leave for over a month. Thankfully my wife is receiving from her job while on maternity leave. Cigna is ridiculous... read more >
Cigna
They should all rot in hell
Cigna had been paying on my LTD policy for 7 months when I reached $100,000 in claims they had paid for me. Immediately my policy I had through my employer changed, the en... read more >
Cigna
They will constantly come up with anything to delay paying you
I have been on disability since august of 2020 and it is now November 2021. I have not seen a dime from them and every time I call it's always something else they need or ... read more >
Cigna
Don't count on Cigna!!! You will be very disappointed!!!
I had complications to a previous hip surgery. I was given some time off to get the issues figured out. During this time I had complications with my prostate gland. I ende... read more >
Cigna
They will do anything to avoid paying
I was under the impression they covered maternity leave until after I had my baby. I worked till the day I had him, my pregnancy was considered pre-existing so I have no c... read more >
Answered Questions by Our Lawyers
(70)
Showing 8 of 70 Answered Questions
Q: Why can Cigna get away with not paying me anything for my disability?
A: Barbara: It sounds like you have a complex situation. Unfortunately, it also sounds like you had legal represe... Read More >
Q: Do I have to be an active employee to apply for LTD?
A: Lori: Generally speaking, if out on claim and a new/different disability arises you can add that to your exist... Read More >
Q: Can Cigna refuse to give me a copy of my short term disability policy?
A: Dave, since the policyholder is your employer CIGNA can refuse to provide it to you. You should contact your e... Read More >
Q: Is my plan governed by ERISA?
A: LeRoy, we will have to review the policy in order to give an opinion as to whether it would be governed by ERI... Read More >
Q: Can I add a physical disability claim to my mental health one without seeing a doctor (hard to get an appointment with COVID)?
A: Heather, the only way to effectively include your physical disability claim is to see a physician qualified to... Read More >
Q: Do you handle CIGNA cases in Florida?
A: Vito, yes. We absolutely do handle Cigna cases in Florida. Please email me at Rachel@diattorney.com and send... Read More >
Q: How can Cigna get away with not answering my calls?
A: Carol, knowing Cigna it sounds like they are approving your claim on appeal for a closed period of time and th... Read More >
Q: Do you handle closed cases only, or open ones as well?
A: Renee, we handle all types of open claims with Cigna – applications, claims handling, appeals, lawsuits, buy... Read More >
Helpful Videos
(834)
Showing 12 of 834 Videos
Disability Benefit Tips
(329)
Showing 8 of 329 Benefit Tips
Is Cigna Seeking To Offset Disability Benefit by Social Security Survivor Benefit?
I recently spoke with a gentleman who called into our office who has been receiving long term disability benefits from Cigna for several years... Read More >
Is Cigna's Denial of Your Appeal Really a Denial?
Following the submission of your appeal has Cigna sent you a letter stating that after review of the information provided on appeal their deci... Read More >
What Should a Claimant Expect When Suing Cigna or any Other Disability Company for Long Term Disability Benefits?
ERISA disability lawsuits are complicated due to the pro-insurance company laws. Our disabili... Read More >
Are Cigna Short Term Disability Denials on the Rise?
When it comes to claims for short term disability benefits under ERISA governed group policies, more often than not the short term disability ... Read More >
Cigna's latest strategies for handling and denying disability benefit claims
Watch Gregory Dell and Stephen Jessup discuss Cigna's latest strategy for handling disability... Read More >
Is a Claimant's Complaints of Pain Enough to Qualify for Short or Long Term Disability Insurance Benefits?
The answer to this question applies to the vast majority of long term disability insurance claims that we handle on a daily basis. Pain is sub... Read More >
Is My Insurance Company Allowed to Take An Offset of My Monthly LTD Benefit for Social Security Benefits My Kids Receive As A Result of My Disability?
It is common practice for insurance companies to find ways to limit the amount of money they have to pay to claimants. If you are receiving lo... Read More >
Is My "No-Fault" Auto Insurance Settlement an Offset Under My Long Term Disability Insurance Policy?
If your policy is an employer provided group disability policy governed by ERISA, then any proceeds you receive from a settlement based on "No... Read More >
Dell Disability Cases
(362)
Showing 8 of 362 Dell Disability Cases
Cigna Sued For Failing To Make A Timely Decision on Appeal
If your disability insurance claim has ever been denied you will have received a formal denial letter from your insurance carrier in which you... Read More >
CIGNA Overturns a Waiver of Premium for Group Life Insurance Policy
In early 2019, the widow of a decease man contacted our firm as she was troubled by the actions of CIGNA, also known as Life Insurance Company... Read More >
Cigna Admits Error In Denying Disability Benefits
Our client, a former school teacher, suffering from multiple severe medical conditions including autonomic nervous system damage, small fiber ... Read More >
CIGNA Overturned Their Denial of LTD Benefits for Nevada Healthcare Coordinator
Our client, Ms. G, formerly worked as a Healthcare Coordinator for a large regional healthcare provider. For many years Ms. G suffered from ch... Read More >
CIGNA Denies Technology Manager under the Own Occupation Provision & Dell Disability Lawyers Wins Appeal
Our client, Mr. N, formerly worked as a Technology Manager / Vice President for a large bank. For many years Mr. N suffered from chronic debil... Read More >
CIGNA overturned previous denial of waiver of life insurance premiums
Our client was the husband and beneficiary of Ms. S, who formerly worked as a registered nurse for a regional Healthcare System. In January 20... Read More >
Dell Disability Lawyers successfully appeal denial of benefits to claimant with CRPS/RSD
Ms. S contacted our firm after receiving a letter from her disability carrier, Cigna, denying her claim for short term disability benefits und... Read More >
LINA overturned its previous LTD denial for Medical Technologist
Our client, Ms. H, formerly worked as a Medical Technologist for a National Clinical Laboratory. In July 2017 a number of medical issues, incl... Read More >
Disability Lawsuit Stories
(763)
Reviews from Our Clients
