Standard Insurance Wins Appellate Remand for Claimant's Own Occupation Disability Determination
Cheney v. Standard Insurance Company and Long Term Disability Insurance (Standard) is a case in which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit sent back to the Illinois District Court for resolution of several issues. One issue concerned whether or not the plaintiff was disabled from working within her own occupation.
Overview of Relevant Facts
In 1991, the plaintiff, Carole Cheney, began working as an attorney for Kirkland & Ellis, LLP (Kirkland). In 1997 she was made a partner. For all her years at Kirkland, she suffered from spinal problems, including degenerative spinal disease. Kirkland granted her request for ergonomic accommodations in 1994. In 2003, due to her health issues, she was allowed to do most of her work at home.
In July 2012, just prior to undergoing a spinal fusion, she applied for long-term disability benefits. Her application was denied and she filed an ERISA law suit in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Illinois. The District Court ordered Standard to pay benefits to Cheney and found she was disabled from working in her own occupation. Standard appealed. The court of appeals found that when the district court determined she was disabled from her own occupation, it erred and “asked the wrong question.” The case was remanded for district court to make findings consistent with the Court of Appeals order.
Standard’s Own Occupation Definition
Under Standard’s policy, a person is considered disabled from their own occupation if they “are unable to perform with reasonable continuity the Material Duties” of their own occupation. “Own Occupation” is defined as employment “of the same general character as the occupation you are regularly performing for your Employer when Disability begins.” The policy continues, “If your Own Occupation necessitates a professional or occupational license, the scope of your Own Occupation is ‘as broad as the scope of your license.’”
In determining that Cheney was disabled from her own occupation, the district court found that she was unable to work as a litigation partner in a big law firm. The district court has specifically stated that whether or not she could work as a lawyer was “not the question.” In fact, the court of appeals found that to be the exact question that needed to be resolved under the terms of the policy, saying “Because the practice of law requires a license, the issue is whether Cheney can find any work—in the same specialty or another, or generally—as a lawyer.” The case was remanded for resolution of this issue.
Inability to Perform Just One Essential Job Task Does Not Qualify Plaintiff for Benefits
The district court seemed to find Cheney was disabled from her own occupation because she was unable to sit at a computer or sit in court. The court of appeals disagreed, noting, “The inability to perform a single material job task does not demonstrate disability within the meaning of this policy.” The court remanded since the district court’s treatment of this issue was “cursory and not supported by evidence from Cheney’s doctors.”
This case was not handled by our office, but it may provide guidance to those who have similar “own occupation” clauses in their disability policies and need help in the interpretation. Feel free to call our disability attorneys for a free consultation on this or any matter relevant to your disability claim.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Submit a Strong Standard Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Standard appeal.
Sue Standard
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Standard.
Get Your Standard Disability Application Approved
Prevent a Standard Disability Benefit Denial
Negotiate a Standard Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Policy Holder Rating
Standard insurance just dropped me with no communication with me.
Reply
Standard is one of, if not the worse, company in the industry now
Standard is one of, if not the worse, company in the industry Standard hasn't approved or denied my claim in over a year. They keep promising to look at it 'next week'
Reply
I waited 5 weeks just to be told I can't receive benefits
Reply
The Standard will threaten to withhold your pay until you sign every document that they send you. The worst part is when they consider back payment for SSDI benefits
Standard's sudden denial was inexplicable
Standard has keep me jumping through hoops for years
Reply
Mental health LTD should be covered under the Mental Health Parity Act
Q: Do I have to pay back LTD after receiving SSDI?
Q: Non-taxable benefits have become taxable.
Q: How do I ensure Standard makes a timely decision with regard to my claim?
Q: Why can my employer hold my disability check after The Standard sends it to them? Can I file a grievance with them?
Q: Should I contact you before submitting my application for a private disability benefit?
Q: Is there any case law in which a state government employee LTD plan decided to drop the 24 month mental health limitation? Has there been any success against a state government and Standard using ADA Title I (employee) and 3 (insurance company) from a discrimination basis?
Q: How can Standard deny my claim and expect me to work when I am disabled?
Q: I'm waiting to hear back about my appeal. Should I hire an attorney?
Applying for Standard Disability Benefits? Top 5 Claim Denial Reasons
How to Prevent Standard Insurance Company from Denying Disability Benefits
Can My Insurance Company Terminate My Disability Benefits After 24 Months if My Mental Nervous Disorder Contributes to But is Not The Sole Cause of My Disability?
Dentist and doctors: beware of the Standard Insurance Company Group's long-term disability policy
Why Must Your Disability Insurance Lawyer Understand Your Disabling Condition?
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #5 – Your Medical Evidence is Weak
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #4 - Your Doctor Is Misled By the Disability Company
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #3 - Video & Social Media Surveillance
Seven Surgeries and The Standard Still Denies Disability Insurance Benefits
After Two Appeals The Standard Insurance Approves Short & Long Term Disability Benefits for Nurse
Standard Approves Disability Benefits to Attorney with Fibromyalgia
Standard overturns decision to deny disabled Project Manager long-term disability insurance benefits after first Appeal
Another long term disability claim is reinstated after Disability Attorney Alexander Palamara successfully argues The Standard mishandled preexisting condition investigation
Standard Overturns Denial of Benefits to Shareholder of Major Law Firm
Disability Attorney Alex Palamara wins LTD Benefits for Police Officer Denied by Standard
Standard Overturns Denial of Disability Insurance Benefits
Reviews from Our Clients






