First Circuit Finds for Plaintiff and Awards Retroactive Mental Health Benefits
In Jane Doe v. Standard Insurance Company, plaintiff Doe spent more than 25 years as an environmental attorney for a Maine law firm prior to become ill with depression and anxiety. She filed a claim for mental health disability benefits under the law firm’s disability policy. Her claim was approved, but based on a disability date of January 2012, when she claimed the date should be October 2011. Standard also awarded benefits based on the general occupation of an attorney instead of her own occupation as an environmental attorney.
After several administrative appeals, Doe filed an ERISA lawsuit in the Maine District Court, which ruled in favor of the insurer and Doe appealed. The Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reversed the lower court decision and ruled that Standard was wrong on both issues. By using the definition of a general attorney instead of environmental attorney the Court stated that Standard “eviscerated the Own Occupation coverage, and its evaluation as to Doe’s disability onset date was based on the wrong standards.”
Onset Date of Disability
On March 22, 2012, plaintiff filed a claim for mental health disability benefits stating she had been unable to work since October 2011. Standard argued she was not disabled until January 28, 2012. The date is significant in that benefits are calculated based on the prior year’s earnings. In this case, the difference in onset made a difference of more than $100,000 in payments.
After reviewing the medical reports and Doe’s work history, the appeals Court agreed that she had become disabled in October 2011. The amount of benefits then turned on whether her own occupation was that of an environmental lawyer or a general lawyer.
Own Occupation Standard
Doe paid an additional premium to Standard in order to have coverage if she was disabled from working in her own occupation: that of an environmental lawyer. When Standard calculated benefits, it did so on the basis of earnings of a general lawyer and used the Dictionary of Occupational Titles (DOT) for the job description and calculation of benefits.
The Court disagreed noting that “No evidence in the record supports the assumption that ‘environmental lawyer’ and ‘lawyer’ are equivalent terms that may be used interchangeably. Environmental law is a distinct specialty, and the expertise demanded from environmental lawyers distinguished that specialty from a generic ‘lawyer’ role.”
After determining that Standard’s use of the 2012 disability onset date was wrong, and the calculation of benefits on the basis of work of a general lawyer instead of an environmental lawyer, the Court then sought to determine the appropriate remedy.
Remedy is to Order Insurer to Pay Retroactive Benefits
The Court noted that it had “considerable latitude” in selecting a remedy in an ERISA case. Plaintiff here suffered through several administrative appeals over several years period of time.
The Court concluded, “We think it most equitable in these circumstances to bring an end to this dispute and to award Doe retroactive benefits instead of remanding the matter to Standard.” It remanded to the district court with orders to Standard to calculate benefits based on the 2011 onset date under plaintiff’s own occupation as an environmental lawyer.
This case was not handled by our office, but we think it can be beneficial to those struggling to obtain long-term disability or mental health benefits based on the policy definition of their own occupation. If you have any questions about your own disability claim, contact one of our attorneys at Dell & Schaefer for a free case evaluation.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Submit a Strong Standard Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Standard appeal.
Sue Standard
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Standard.
Get Your Standard Disability Application Approved
Prevent a Standard Disability Benefit Denial
Negotiate a Standard Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Policy Holder Rating
Standard insurance just dropped me with no communication with me.
Reply
Standard is one of, if not the worse, company in the industry now
Standard is one of, if not the worse, company in the industry Standard hasn't approved or denied my claim in over a year. They keep promising to look at it 'next week'
Reply
I waited 5 weeks just to be told I can't receive benefits
Reply
The Standard will threaten to withhold your pay until you sign every document that they send you. The worst part is when they consider back payment for SSDI benefits
Standard's sudden denial was inexplicable
Standard has keep me jumping through hoops for years
Reply
Mental health LTD should be covered under the Mental Health Parity Act
Q: Do I have to pay back LTD after receiving SSDI?
Q: Non-taxable benefits have become taxable.
Q: How do I ensure Standard makes a timely decision with regard to my claim?
Q: Why can my employer hold my disability check after The Standard sends it to them? Can I file a grievance with them?
Q: Should I contact you before submitting my application for a private disability benefit?
Q: Is there any case law in which a state government employee LTD plan decided to drop the 24 month mental health limitation? Has there been any success against a state government and Standard using ADA Title I (employee) and 3 (insurance company) from a discrimination basis?
Q: How can Standard deny my claim and expect me to work when I am disabled?
Q: I'm waiting to hear back about my appeal. Should I hire an attorney?
Applying for Standard Disability Benefits? Top 5 Claim Denial Reasons
How to Prevent Standard Insurance Company from Denying Disability Benefits
Can My Insurance Company Terminate My Disability Benefits After 24 Months if My Mental Nervous Disorder Contributes to But is Not The Sole Cause of My Disability?
Dentist and doctors: beware of the Standard Insurance Company Group's long-term disability policy
Why Must Your Disability Insurance Lawyer Understand Your Disabling Condition?
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #5 – Your Medical Evidence is Weak
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #4 - Your Doctor Is Misled By the Disability Company
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #3 - Video & Social Media Surveillance
Seven Surgeries and The Standard Still Denies Disability Insurance Benefits
After Two Appeals The Standard Insurance Approves Short & Long Term Disability Benefits for Nurse
Standard Approves Disability Benefits to Attorney with Fibromyalgia
Standard overturns decision to deny disabled Project Manager long-term disability insurance benefits after first Appeal
Another long term disability claim is reinstated after Disability Attorney Alexander Palamara successfully argues The Standard mishandled preexisting condition investigation
Standard Overturns Denial of Benefits to Shareholder of Major Law Firm
Disability Attorney Alex Palamara wins LTD Benefits for Police Officer Denied by Standard
Standard Overturns Denial of Disability Insurance Benefits
Reviews from Our Clients






