Baxter International Systems Analyst With Cervical Radiculopathy Wins Wisconsin Lincoln Financial LTD Insurance Appeal After Any Occupation Denial

Lincoln Financial paid our client’s long-term disability benefits for more than two years. Then a physician who never examined her read the file on paper and decided she could sit without restriction, use both hands all day, and lift 20 pounds. The checks stopped that month.
Our client is a systems analyst for Baxter International in Wisconsin. She lives with cervical spinal stenosis and nerve damage running from her neck into both arms after multilevel fusion surgery, along with several other spinal, joint and inflammatory conditions. Terminations like hers cluster at the any occupation review, and this is a playbook our long-term disability lawyers have taken apart many times.
Attorney Stephen Jessup filed the appeal, and Lincoln reinstated the claim in full with every withheld payment. What forced that result was not sympathy. It was a series of documented failures inside Lincoln’s own review, and anyone holding a termination letter should understand them. If Lincoln Financial or any other disability insurance company has stopped your benefits, speak with one of our lawyers anywhere in the country, with no fee unless we get your benefits paid.
Table Of Contents
- 1. Why this case matters for every Lincoln Financial claimant
- 2. Two years of benefits, then the definition changed
- 3. The paper review that contradicted its own findings
- 4. Five sedentary jobs built on a functional profile that did not exist
- 5. The FCE tested what the paper review only assumed
- 6. Her treating neurosurgeon confirmed the cervical and lumbar findings
- 7. Lincoln had already reversed this same claim once
- 8. Lincoln reopens the claim and pays everything it withheld
- 9. If your long-term disability insurance benefits have been terminated
Why This Case Matters for Every Lincoln Financial Claimant
A paper review is an opinion about you, not an examination of you. A paper review, also called a file review or a peer review, is an assessment in which a physician hired by the insurer reads your records and assigns physical restrictions without ever meeting you, touching you, or testing you. Lincoln terminated this claim on exactly that basis. No examination, no measurement, no contact with our client at all.
Objective testing beats an estimate every time, so get the testing done after the insurer commits. We obtained an updated Functional Capacity Evaluation after Lincoln’s reviewer had already locked in her numbers. That sequence matters. It let the testing confront each specific assumption rather than float alongside it. For neck and cervical disorder disability claimants, whose claims turn on fine distinctions in sitting tolerance and hand function, measured numbers are what move a file.
An insurer that already paid your claim has to explain what improved. Claimants ask us whether a disability insurance company can stop benefits after paying for years. It can, and this is how. Lincoln had reversed a denial on this same claim the year before, after finding that her limited hand use ruled out her own occupation. The new review simply upgraded her hands from occasional to frequent, with nothing in the record showing they had improved.
Read the credentials the denial letter claims, then check them. Lincoln’s letter described a neurologist. The report it relied on was written by someone else entirely. When an insurer misstates who evaluated you, the reliability of everything built on that evaluation is fair game.
A vague agreement from your doctor can be turned into a weapon. One of our client’s treating physicians sent back an unexplained note saying she agreed with the reviewer’s notes. Lincoln treated those few words as an endorsement of an eight-page report. Your doctors need to know that a casual reply to an insurer is not casual at all.
Two Years of Benefits, Then the Definition Changed
Most group long-term disability insurance policies pay under two different standards. For the first 24 months, benefits are owed if you cannot perform your own occupation. After that, benefits continue only if you cannot perform, with reasonable continuity, the material and substantial duties of any occupation for which you are reasonably fitted by training, education, experience, age, and physical and mental capacity.
Baxter International’s policy, administered by The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, uses that structure. Lincoln quoted it back in the termination letter:
“‘Any Occupation’ means any occupation that the Covered Person is or becomes reasonably fitted by training, education, experience, age, physical and mental capacity.”
Material and substantial duties are the responsibilities normally required to perform an occupation that cannot reasonably be eliminated or modified. They are the parts of the job you cannot simply drop.
What happens at the 24-month mark is the question behind most of the terminations we handle. That shift from own occupation to any occupation is the single most dangerous moment in a group disability insurance claim. It is where insurers reopen files they have been paying quietly for years.
What Her Job Actually Required
Our client performed skilled information technology and engineering work at the sedentary physical demand level. The job demanded prolonged sitting at a computer workstation, sustained keyboarding and fingering, manual dexterity, concentration, consistent productivity, and the ability to show up on a reliable schedule.
Those last two items carry more weight than claimants often realize. A technical job is not a series of isolated tasks. It is sustained output over a full workday, every workday.

The Conditions in the Record
Her file documented cervical spinal stenosis (ICD-10 M48.02), a narrowing of the spinal canal in the neck, and post-fusion cervical radiculopathy (ICD-10 M54.12), which is nerve root irritation in the neck that sends pain, numbness and weakness down into the arms and hands. Her cervical spine had been surgically fused from C4 through C7, locking four vertebrae in the neck together and permanently removing motion at those levels.
The record went well beyond her neck:
- Lumbar degenerative disease confirmed on MRI at the L5-S1 level, the lowest segment of the lower back, with pain radiating into the right leg
- Bilateral sacroiliac joint osteoarthritis on imaging, in the joints that connect the base of the spine to the pelvis
- Progressive avascular necrosis of both femoral heads, a condition in which bone tissue dies from loss of blood supply and the joint can eventually collapse
- Degenerative changes of the left first carpometacarpal joint, at the base of the thumb
- Psoriatic arthritis, an inflammatory arthritis that occurs with psoriasis
- Fibromyalgia (ICD-10 M79.7) with documented tender points, plus myofascial pain, which arises from the muscles and the tissue surrounding them
- Measured grip ability of 70 percent, with decreased pinprick sensation in the left hand
Read that list against the job description and the conflict is obvious. Her hands were compromised in a role built on her hands. Her spine was compromised in a role built on sitting still.
The Paper Review That Contradicted Its Own Findings
Lincoln’s termination rested on a peer review by Dr. Annie Layno-Moses. She never examined our client. She read the file. Whether medical file reviews accurately reflect a disability insurance claim depends entirely on what the reviewer does with the records, and this one is a case study in how badly it can go.
A Reviewer Whose Specialty the Denial Letter Got Wrong
Lincoln’s letter told our office this:
“The available records were reviewed by a consulting physician, Board-Certified in Neurology.”
Dr. Layno-Moses is board-certified in physical medicine and rehabilitation, with a specialty in pain medicine. She is not a neurologist. As attorney Stephen Jessup put it in the appeal, Lincoln’s characterization “materially misstates the nature of the review upon which it relied.”
This is not a technicality. An insurer that cannot accurately describe who evaluated your claim has handed you a reason to question how carefully it evaluated anything else.
Findings That Pointed One Way, Restrictions That Pointed the Other
Dr. Layno-Moses acknowledged almost everything in the medical record. She recognized the post-fusion cervical radiculopathy, the reduced sensation, the reduced grip strength, the L5-S1 degeneration, the sacroiliac osteoarthritis, the worsening avascular necrosis, the thumb joint degeneration and the fibromyalgia. She even wrote that the worsening hip disease required limits on standing, walking and climbing to reduce the risk of joint collapse.
Then she assigned restrictions that looked nothing like those findings:
- “Sitting: Unrestricted”
- Reaching at desk level: unrestricted, both arms
- Fine manipulation, simple grasping and firm grasping: frequently, both hands
- Lifting, carrying, pushing and pulling: occasionally, up to 20 pounds
- Standing, walking, stair climbing, balancing, stooping, kneeling and crouching: occasionally
Unrestricted Sitting, With Nothing Behind It
Unrestricted sitting was the load-bearing wall of Lincoln’s entire decision. Our client’s job required her to stay seated at a workstation for most of the day. If she could not do that, no amount of vocational analysis would save the denial.
Yet the review cited no examination, no functional testing, and no quantified sitting assessment of any kind. It was an assumption dressed as a finding. Her own acknowledgment that our client’s spinal disease limited sustained postural positions sat in direct conflict with it.
Cervical Radiculopathy, Reduced Grip, and the Jump to Frequent Hand Use
The same problem ran through the upper-extremity conclusions, and the vocabulary matters here. In vocational terms, “occasionally” and “frequently” are not loose words. Federal guidance defines occasional activity as occurring up to one-third of the workday and frequent activity as occurring between one-third and two-thirds of it. In an 8-hour day, that is the gap between using your hands for under three hours and using them for more than five.
The record documented cervical radiculopathy, bilateral hand numbness, decreased pinprick sensation (a reduced ability to feel a sharp point on examination, which signals nerve damage), chronic hand pain, thumb joint degeneration and grip ability measured at 70 percent of normal. Losing roughly a third of your grip is the difference between typing through a full workday and losing hold of the keyboard by mid-afternoon.
Dr. Layno-Moses concluded our client could perform fine manipulation and both simple and firm grasping frequently, throughout a full workday. The review never explained how. That gap is the whole case.
Five Sedentary Jobs Built on a Functional Profile That Did Not Exist
Lincoln then sent the file to a vocational specialist. A vocational analysis, sometimes called a transferable skills analysis, takes the restrictions assigned by the insurer’s medical reviewer and searches for occupations a person with those exact restrictions could theoretically hold.
The output was five sedentary occupations:
- Systems Analyst, her own occupation, at $8,649.33 per month
- Computer Systems Hardware Analyst, at $9,080.93 per month
- Order Department Supervisor, at $7,011.33 per month
- Credit Analyst, at $6,747.87 per month
- Claim Examiner, at $6,399.47 per month
Look at the first entry. Lincoln was not only saying our client could work somewhere else. It was saying she could go back to the very job it had already agreed she could not perform.
There was a second defect. The reviewer had credited our client with occasional lifting, carrying, pushing and pulling of up to 20 pounds. Federal regulations define sedentary work as involving lifting no more than 10 pounds at a time. Dr. Layno-Moses had built a theoretical capacity approaching light work, a level above the job our client actually held.
Restrictions that exceed the exertional demands of a claimant’s own occupation are a warning sign. They describe a theoretical physical capacity rather than an assessment of whether that person can actually hold a job.
Claimants ask us about this constantly: if my job was already sedentary, can the insurance company point me to another sedentary job? It can, and it will. The answer is to attack the functional profile the list was built from, which is the same approach that won the appeal for an IT systems analyst with inflammatory arthritis, a claimant who was denied twice before we got her reinstated.
The FCE Tested What the Paper Review Only Assumed
A Functional Capacity Evaluation is a structured, hands-on examination in which a licensed evaluator measures what a person can physically do: how long they can sit, how long they can stand, how much they can lift, how well they can grip, and how consistently they perform across hours of testing.
We obtained an updated FCE after Dr. Layno-Moses had already issued her opinion. That timing was deliberate. A Functional Capacity Evaluation performed after the insurer’s paper review is the most direct way to rebut it, because the testing measures the exact capacities the reviewer only estimated.
The results:
- Unable to sit more than roughly 15 minutes without changing position, against the approximately 6 hours a workday requires
- Unable to stand more than roughly 3 minutes without resting
- Lifting capacity of 4 pounds bilaterally and 4 pounds to shoulder height, with no overhead lifting capacity at all
- Only occasional tolerance for simple grasping, pinching, walking, forward reaching, bending and squatting
- Firm grasping, above-shoulder reaching, static balance and stair climbing all to be avoided in a competitive work environment
- Consistent effort demonstrated on 92.9 percent of testing, with reliable pain reporting on 100 percent of testing
Those last figures do real work. Insurers routinely argue that poor performance on testing reflects low motivation rather than true impairment. Validity measures at that level close the door on that argument before it opens.
The evaluator’s conclusion was that our client could not work full time and that even the unskilled sedentary occupational base was significantly eroded. That is the finding vocational experts call Less Than Sedentary.
A claimant is Less Than Sedentary when measured functional capacity falls below the lightest exertional level recognized in vocational analysis, meaning no full-time occupation in the national economy fits. In plain terms: she could not sustain a desk job, let alone the technical one Lincoln wanted to send her back to.
Attorney Jessup framed the comparison directly in the appeal:
“There is no reasonable basis to favor the unsupported estimate of a non-examining reviewer over contemporaneous, performance-based testing demonstrating a markedly lower capacity.”
Her Treating Neurosurgeon Confirmed the Cervical and Lumbar Findings
Objective testing is powerful. Objective testing endorsed by the specialist who actually operated on your spine is harder to dismiss.
An Attending Physician Statement (APS) is the standardized form an insurer sends to a treating doctor requesting diagnoses, restrictions and an opinion on work capacity. Our client’s treating neurosurgeon completed an updated APS for the appeal, reviewed the FCE directly, and agreed with its findings.
He then set out the objective signs behind her limitations, meaning findings a physician can observe or measure rather than symptoms a patient reports:
- MRI abnormalities
- Muscle weakness and reduced strength
- Joint swelling and stiffness
- Visible fatigue and decreased endurance
- Impaired sensation and numbness
- Decreased range of motion
- Heart rate changes
- Tender points and tenderness to palpation
He went further on the practical question that decides these claims. If our client attempted to work, he concluded, she would frequently require unscheduled interruptions, frequently miss work because of symptom flares, and frequently remain off task.
Then he anchored it in time. These limitations, he confirmed, had existed since at least the date Lincoln terminated the claim. No gap for the insurer to argue into.
Lincoln Had Already Reversed This Same Claim Once
The strongest material in this appeal came out of Lincoln’s own file.
The Prior Reversal It Never Explained Away
The year before this termination, Lincoln had reviewed the same claim and concluded that restrictions limiting fine manipulation and simple and firm grasping to occasional use prevented our client from performing her own occupation, which required frequent fingering, keyboarding and typing. Lincoln overturned that earlier denial and accepted liability, because no alternate occupations could be identified.
Then came the new review, which identified no meaningful improvement in her hand symptoms, sensation, grip strength, spinal disease or systemic pain. Dr. Layno-Moses simply moved her hand-use capacity from occasional to frequent.
That is not a medical finding. That is a different number, written by a different reviewer, on the same facts. The hip disease had actually progressed in the interim.
A carrier that has previously accepted liability must identify genuine medical improvement before it can increase a claimant’s assessed functional capacity. Lincoln identified none.
Three Words Turned Into an Endorsement
Lincoln also leaned on a response from one of our client’s treating physicians, an internal medicine specialist, whose claim note recorded that she agreed with the peer review, or “agreed with notes.” This is precisely why your doctor should never speak with a disability insurance company without your permission.
Nothing identified which portion of an eight-page report she accepted. Not the diagnoses, not the history, not the specific functional capacities, not the ultimate conclusion about work capacity. As the appeal argued:
“Lincoln therefore improperly transformed a vague response into an endorsement of the entire peer review when the record does not support such an inference.”
Worse, that response arrived only after the claim had already been closed. Lincoln never sought clarification, never asked the physician to address sitting tolerance or manual limitations, and never obtained a completed functional assessment from her. The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) requires plans to give denied claimants a full and fair review of the decision. Converting an ambiguous one-line note into blanket medical agreement is the opposite of that.
We see this pattern constantly. It is the same dynamic that ran through our appeal for a financial services director with neck, back and hip conditions, a Lincoln termination we also reversed.
Lincoln Reopens the Claim and Pays Everything It Withheld
Lincoln did not argue. It reversed.
The approval letter was brief and unambiguous:
“Upon review of additional information provided, we have determined the medical evidence submitted supports [our client’s] claim for benefits. Therefore, her claim has been reopened and she will receive benefits dating back to May 6, 2026.”
Every withheld payment was restored. That is the outcome a complete appeal record produces, and it mirrors what happened for an occupational therapy assistant cut off at the 24-month mark, another any occupation denial we reversed with back benefits paid.
One caution worth stating plainly. Lincoln’s letter also warned that approval does not guarantee payment through the maximum benefit duration and that the claim will be evaluated periodically. A reinstatement is not the end of the file. It is the start of the next review cycle, and the evidence you build now is what you will stand on then.
If Your Long-Term Disability Insurance Benefits Have Been Terminated
Attorney Stephen Jessup closed the appeal with a line that applies to almost every termination we see:
“Lincoln cannot reasonably rely upon a peer reviewer’s unsupported increase in functional capacity while disregarding both the treating evidence and objective functional testing.”
If your benefits have been cut off, the clock is already running. An administrative appeal is the mandatory internal review an ERISA plan must provide before a claimant can file suit, and it is where all of your evidence has to land. Federal ERISA claims procedure regulations give disability claimants at least 180 days from the denial to file it.
That window is not a formality. It is your only opportunity to build the record, because in most cases a court will later decide your claim on the file you submit during the appeal and nothing more. Miss it, and the evidence that would have won your case never gets considered.
Our disability insurance attorneys have represented claimants nationwide since our firm was established in 1979. We have helped tens of thousands of claimants and recovered more than $2 billion in disability insurance benefits from every major carrier.
Contact our office for a free consultation to speak with one of our lawyers about your claim. We represent claimants in every state, and we collect no fee unless we get your benefits paid.













