Texas Judge Rules No New Medical Evidence Allowed Post ERISA Disability Appeal
In Hutchings v. Lora Lyons, Plan Administrator, and Ball Industries Employee Injury Benefit Plan, et al. (Defendants), plaintiff Linda Hutchings injured her knee while at work. Her initial request for disability benefits was granted so she could have surgery for a torn right medial meniscus. The surgery was not successful.
Just a few months later, she requested disability benefits so she could have a total knee replacement surgery and her request was denied. Defendants claimed it was a preexisting condition. Hutchings’ administrative appeal was denied and she subsequently filed this ERISA lawsuit. She filed the administrative record at the same time.
A week later, defendants filed additional attachments, including an eight-page report by a medical doctor who had reviewed the plaintiff’s medical records. Plaintiff moved to strike the report since she had never seen it before and it was not part of the administrative record. Defendants objected, claiming the report would be helpful to the Court since it “synthesized” hundreds of pages of medical records.
The Court decided in favor of the plaintiff and held the new report was inadmissible. Plaintiff had never had an opportunity to rebut its contents and it did not fall under any exception to the rule that no new evidence can be submitted after the administrative appeal is finished.
The Medical Report Did Not Fit Under Either of the Two Exceptions That Allow a Court to Consider Evidence Outside the Administrative Record
The District court relied on Fifth Circuit precedent that makes it clear that “when assessing factual questions, the district court is constrained to the evidence before the plan administrator.” There are two exceptions to this rule:
1. Evidence that shows how an administrator has interpreted the terms of the plan in other similar cases.
2. The evidence assists the court “in understanding the medical terminology or practice related to a claim.”
Defendants argued the evidence fell into the second exception and would assist the court in understanding the medical terminology or practice. The court disagreed.
The Medical Report is Not One That Assists the Court in Understanding Medical Terminology
The court noted its job is “to review the record as the Administrator had it when she denied the claim.” It was undisputed that this report was generated nearly a year after the defendants had denied plaintiff’s claim. There was nothing purported to be in the report that would aid the court in understanding medical terminology or practice, but was only a “synthesized” version of her medical records. Accordingly, the court held that its admission would be only “cumulative and unnecessary.”
Plaintiff Did Not Waive her Right to Object
Defendants then argued that Hutchings waited too long to object to the inclusion of the report in the file. The court disagreed with this argument, noting the report was filed nearly a year after the denial of Hutchings’ “employee injury claim.” She made her objection approximately 10 weeks after the 1,000 plus pages of her administrative record was filed with the court, which was a reasonable period. Accordingly, the court deemed her objection was timely and the report was “not properly before the court.” The report was stricken from the administrative record.
This case was not handled by our office, but we believe it can be instructive to those who may be faced with a similar situation. If you have questions about this case, or any question concerning our disability benefits, contact us at Dell & Schaefer for a free consultation.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Disability Benefit Denial Options
Submit a Strong Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong appeal.
Sue Your Disability Insurance Company
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide.
Protect Your Benefits
Get Your Disability Application Approved
We help claimants throughout the entire application process.
Prevent a Disability Benefit Denial
We manage every aspect of your disability claim following claim approval.
Negotiate a Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Disability Company Reviews
(627)
Showing 8 of 627 Reviews
Sun Life
What a mess
This place has no idea what day it even is. First they attach my claim to my previous claim in which was a new claim. They messed up and denied me then made me wait yet ag... read more >
Reply
Sedgwick
I was disabled 2003 by SS. I got SSDI 7 years too late.
I believe if Sedgwick would have moved on my Claim. They absolutely did everything not to answer my calls, change dates. I had already been through WV comp. Ins. Sold out,... read more >
MetLife
Only care about $$$$$
PLAY THEIR GAME FIGHT FIRE WITH FIRE.....after getting a copy of the insurance policy from my HR. I nipped a lot of the headaches quickly by calling their bluff word for w... read more >
Reply
Sedgwick
They falsify documents and avoid contact as much as possible.
They avoided sending the documents needed for the claim for two weeks. I had to escalate with a call from my company's HR and Sedgwick (the only way I was ever able to get... read more >
Hartford
This company is a scam!
The Hartford does not pay claims. The Hartford only collects premiums. The Hartford doesn’t care if you are terminally ill. I’ve been employed at my employer since 201... read more >
Prudential
California State Disabilty "OFFSET" never mentioned or outlined when enrolling for STD coverage.
All terms and conditions of receiving a claim benefit not made available when enrolling. Hidden elements of eligibility... not fully transparent with issues that might eff... read more >
Sedgwick
Not getting paid
I been battling Sedgwick about my claim. I was to get paid today and I did not get paid.Sledges is the worse company I ever had to deal with. I been fighting with my b... read more >
Sedgwick
Sedgewich is the worst-immediate denial of all requests for treatment. Rubber stamps DENIED ALL RFA’s
Sedgewich immediately denies all RFA. They’re ur team are THEMSELVES not a independent medical team…
Answered Questions by Our Lawyers
(0)
Helpful Videos
(805)
Showing 12 of 805 Videos
Disability Benefit Tips
(329)
Showing 8 of 329 Benefit Tips
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #4 - Your Doctor Is Misled By the Disability Company
When you're seeking disability benefits under a long term disability policy, your medical rec... Read More >
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #3 - Video & Social Media Surveillance
One thing many long term disability claimants don't know about (or expect) from the claims re... Read More >
How Do You Fight a Long-Term Disability Denial?
Getting a denial letter from your disability insurance company is one of the ultimate insults... Read More >
Disability Denial Reason #2 - Change of Disability Definition & Vocational Review
One of the top reasons for terminating a claimant's long term disability benefits involves th... Read More >
Disability Denial Reason #1 – Paper Review & IME
At Dell Disability Lawyers, we've seen insurance companies give countless reasons to deny lon... Read More >
How to Apply for Reliance Standard Disability Benefits & Top 5 Reasons for a Claim Denial
At Dell & Schaefer we’ve handled hundreds of long term disability insurance claims against Reliance Standard, and have learned a few thi... Read More >
Applying for Standard Disability Benefits? Top 5 Claim Denial Reasons
At Dell & Schaefer, we've helped hundreds of clients recover long term disability benefit... Read More >
Guardian Disability Benefit Claim Handling Tips
When you finally receive a letter from Guardian Disability informing you that your claim for ... Read More >
Dell Disability Cases
(360)
Showing 8 of 360 Dell Disability Cases
FPL Lineman Wins Lincoln Disability Denial Appeal
Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston improperly denied our client’s long-term disabilit... Read More >
Anesthesiologist Approved for Long Term Disability Benfits Plus an Extra 9 Months of Benefits
Our client, an Anesthesiologist, suffered a fall at his home which resulted in rupturing his ... Read More >
Attorney Alexander Palamara of Dell Disability Lawyers gets LTD Benefits Reinstated for former Walmart Manager who is now found disabled from Any Occupation
A former Manager of Quality Assurance at Walmart is again receiving Long Term Disability (LTD) benefits following an appeal filed by Dell Disa... Read More >
Research Epidemiologist with chronic fatigue / ME wins LTD appeal against Prudential
Our client is a former Mental Health Epidemiologist who unfortunately suffered the progressive onset of perv... Read More >
Executive Director with Meniere's Denied Long Term Disability Insurance Benefits By Hartford
Our client, came to us when he was unjustly denied his claim for LTD benefits by Aetna, now Hartford, assert... Read More >
Lincoln Approves Long Term Disability Benefits After Four Year Fight
With financial protections afforded to disability insurance companies under ERISA that insulate them from extra contractual damages there is v... Read More >
Cigna Sued For Failing To Make A Timely Decision on Appeal
If your disability insurance claim has ever been denied you will have received a formal denial letter from your insurance carrier in which you... Read More >
Lincoln National LTD Denial for Pre-Existing Condition Reversed on Appeal
On December 8th of 2020, a new employee at ServerCentral, now known as Deft, a well-known IT ... Read More >
Disability Lawsuit Stories
(763)
Reviews from Our Clients
