Pennsylvania Court rules that CIGNA disability insurance policy allows for offset of lost wages from auto insurance policy
A District Court ruling issued in Scranton, Pennsylvania highlights the importance of understanding the terms of a long-term disability insurance policy. It is common for these disability insurance policies to reduce monthly disability benefits by other benefits or income a claimant receives. This case is a good example of the complex language in disability insurance policies which can be subject to multiple interpretations.
In this case, claimant Joseph George was injured in a non-work related automobile accident in January of 2006. He worked for PPL Services Corporation, which provided him with a group long-term disability policy managed by CIGNA’s subsidiary Life Insurance Company of America (LINA). The policy stipulated that the maximum benefit he could receive each month was $5,000. The policy also stated that this amount could be reduced by “other income benefits.”
CIGNA Policy Reduces Benefits by “Other Income”
The CIGNA disability insurance policy defined what some of these “other income benefits” were. Social Security disability benefits were considered eligible benefits for reducing LINA’s payout. Proceeds from any group insurance or similar plan, were also considered “other benefits.” Disbursements from unemployment or workmen’s comp were listed. The policy also listed specifically “any benefits received from coverage subject to the mandatory part of the vehicle financial responsibility law;” and “any amounts paid on account of loss of earnings or earning capacity through settlement, judgment, arbitration or otherwise, where a third party may be liable, regardless of whether liability is determined.
The disability policy paid 60% of his monthly covered earnings of $4,705.65. This meant that CIGNA’s first benefit check in August 2006 was $2,823. When the disability insurance plan found out two months later that he was receiving monthly wage loss benefits from his automobile insurance policy with Liberty Mutual for $1,500.00, it reduced his CIGNA disability monthly benefit to $1,323 per month and asserted that George owed them $3,000 in overpaid disability benefits.
ERISA Disability Attorney Files Suit For Underpayment of Benefits
George’s disability insurance attorney filed an ERISA disability lawsuit against CIGNA for failing to pay him his full benefits. The disability insurance lawyer argued that Cigna violated ERISA by not paying his client all the benefits he was entitled to. He contended that the wage loss payments were not “other income benefits” and that LINA only had to reduce the $5,000 maximum monthly benefit before it could reduce the $2,823 payment which reflected less than 60% of the earnings George had brought in before his accident.
Court Considers Disability Benefit Plan Language
The Court’s first concern was to identify whether there was any ambiguity in the policy language. It would consider the “(1) the words of the contract; (2) the alternative meaning suggested by counsel; and (3) the nature of the objective evidence to be offered in support of that meaning.” The Court would have to look at the entire policy and construe its meaning as a whole.
What did the Court find? The CIGNA/Lina disability benefit policy clearly stated that it intended to reduce the disability benefits it had to pay out if other income sources arose. The policy covered just about every possible source of potential income:
- Local, state, provincial, or federal government disability or retirement plans that George might qualify for
- Any sick leave he qualified for
- Social Security disability benefits he might be awarded
- Retirement plan benefits
- Unemployment benefits he might claim
- Compensation payments
- “Any wage or salary for work performed”
- Any benefits received due to mandatory vehicle insurance requirements
- “Any amounts paid on account of loss of earnings or earning capacity through settlement, judgment, arbitration or otherwise”
LINA pointed to this list. The Liberty Mutual payment of $1,500 fit both the mandatory insurance requirement definition and the settlement definition. LINA pointed to the fact that Pennsylvania law required automobile insurance policies to provide wage loss coverage of up to $50,000. George’s policy covered him up to $25,000. Thus the $1,500 disbursement fell squarely under LINA’s definition of “other income sources.”
George’s disability insurance lawyer argued that when his client read the long-term disability policy, he understood that only benefits which he had to purchase insurance to receive would offset his disability benefit payments. He also understood that he would receive more benefits, up to $5,000 a month. His attorney argued that this was a reasonable interpretation of the plan language, and thus the Court should enter judgment in his favor.
The Court found otherwise. In context of the entire policy document, it was clear that LINA’s policy was designed to reduce its obligation to pay out long-term disability benefits. One clause was especially applicable. CIGNA/LINA included “any amounts paid on account of loss of earnings.” The Liberty Mutual payments were specifically wage loss payment compensation.
Disability Attorney Argues Basis of Calculation of Benefit Reduction
George’s disability attorney’s final argument was that the policy did not state that the offset would be applied against the 60% calculation. What the policy actually stated was that the amount payable in the event of a claim would be the “lesser of 60% of an Employee’s Monthly Covered Earnings rounded to the nearest dollar or the Maximum Disability Benefit, reduced by any Other Income Benefits.” The disability lawyer argued that the phrase “reduced by any other income benefits” applied only to the maximum disability benefit. This would mean that George should expect that any other income benefits would be subtracted from $5,000 and only impact his benefit from LINA when the other income benefits exceeded $2177. For LINA to subtract the $1500 from the 60% figure breached the policy.
The comma before “reduced by any other income benefits” would prove George’s enemy. The Court failed to recognize that it would be possible for an ordinary individual to be confused by the wording of the phrase, and thus failed to construe the phrase in a manner that was favorable to George as the policy holder. The Court upheld the reasonableness of LINA’s interpretation that first it would calculate the disability benefit using the formula “lesser of 60% of an Employee’s Monthly Covered Earnings rounded to the nearest dollar or the Maximum Disability Benefit.” Then it would offset any benefits by any income listed in the policy.
The Court’s final ruling was in favor of CIGNA. George would have to pay the disability insurance plan $3000 for excess benefits.
This case highlights how important it is to understand what a disability benefit plan provides. Disability Insurance Plans with benefit offsets like CIGNA/LINA’s are common. Most policies require claimants to apply for Social Security benefits so the disability plan’s insurance payments are reduced. Insurance settlements are usually covered in the plan language as it was in this case.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Disability Benefit Denial Options
Submit a Strong Cigna Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Cigna appeal.
Sue Cigna
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Cigna.
Protect Your Benefits
Get Your Cigna Disability Application Approved
We help claimants throughout the entire application process.
Prevent a Cigna Disability Benefit Denial
We manage every aspect of your disability claim following claim approval.
Negotiate a Cigna Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Cigna Reviews
(656)
Policy Holder Rating
5
0%
4
0%
3
0%
2
0%
1
0%
Timely Payments
0.0out of 5
Handling Claim
0.0out of 5
Customer Service
0.0out of 5
Dependable
0.0out of 5
Value
0.0out of 5
Showing 8 of 656 Reviews
Sedgwick
Don't trust them, they like to play games
They suck the life out of people that need help. They falsely advertise for helping people that they care. Sorry to tell you it's all about money, they do not care for any... read more >
New York Life
Lyme Disease Disability Claim Denial
I have had repeat claims for genuine medical leave and they have repeatedly been denied by NY Life. I have even been diagnosed with Lyme and going through treatments and t... read more >
New York Life
Disappointed with NY Life Disability Excuses
I am beyond disappointed with NY Life Disability Insurance’s handling of my father’s claim. My father, a 66-year-old man who has suffered two strokes and continues to ... read more >
New York Life
New York Life is a joke!
This company sucks when it comes to disability claims. They are slow at processing stuff, then they always say they didn't recieve the doctors information. You spend your ... read more >
MetLife
They FULL OF ****
MetLife is what everyone on this review are saying. They don't contact you to let you know what's going on with your claim or to let know you need additional info. I had a... read more >
Sedgwick
Worst Company Ever
If something happens to you at work you better hope you die, my son is going through HELL because this company is handling his work comp. NO RETURN PHONE CALLS, TEXTS, EMA... read more >
MetLife
MetLife for disability? Avoid the surgery unless it's life-threatening
The worst company I ever dealt with, never received a call from my claim manager.
Reliance Standard
Short Term Disability Claim/Inconsistent to NO Communication
When I did call & reach a live person they were kind & helpful. The person assigned to my claim left one phone message & I have not spoken to her since. Information she re... read more >
Answered Questions by Our Lawyers
(48)
Showing 8 of 48 Answered Questions
Q: I filed an appeal and lost. Is it worth pursuing?
A: Kim, in my opinion, yes. If you are still within your timeframe to file a lawsuit you have little to lose in t... Read More >
Q: Do I have a case for STD? I was denied twice because a) I hadn't been a fulltime employee for 6 months and b) I had ben on FMLA since Febury.
A: Frank, we would need to see a copy of the denial letter and the policy. Please feel free to contact our office... Read More >
Q: How can I appeal Cigna's decision if there are no written communications explanation the reasons for claim termination?
A: Tret, Cigna will be required by law to provide you with a written denial letter setting forth its reason for t... Read More >
Q: Is there a process for appeals not being responded to in the time given? Also, how do I access my records?
A: SB, ERISA provides 45 days to render a decision on appeal with the possibility of a 45 day extension- basicall... Read More >
Q: Is it worth is to go to court over $2500?
A: Mark, If you have no additional appeals your only option would be to find representation to file a federal law... Read More >
Q: How long will it take Cigna to get back to me? Will my military retiree pay be held against my policy 60%? Will Cigna exploit the disparity in the medical community over my illness?
A: Craig, Unfortunately it can sometime take up to 45 days to receive a decision from Cigna as to your entitlemen... Read More >
Q: Do I have any options to void an agreement I signed? Can Signa offset my SSDI benefits?
A: Donna, I do not know if you would have any avenues to void the agreement you signed. Regardless of agreeing th... Read More >
Q: Can I sue Cigna even if they do end up paying me?
A: Linda, If your policy is governed by ERISA you will need to go through the administrative appeal process prior... Read More >
Helpful Videos
(908)
Showing 12 of 908 Videos
Disability Benefit Tips
(331)
Showing 8 of 331 Benefit Tips
Is Cigna Seeking To Offset Disability Benefit by Social Security Survivor Benefit?
I recently spoke with a gentleman who called into our office who has been receiving long term disability benefits from Cigna for several years and is also receiving Social Security disability benefits. Employer provided disability policies contain what is known as an “Other Income” provision that identifies all the sources of income that will offset your monthly benefit- the most common of which is Social ... Read More >
Is Cigna's Denial of Your Appeal Really a Denial?
Following the submission of your appeal has Cigna sent you a letter stating that after review of the information provided on appeal their decision to deny your claim was correct but also providing you a copy of their medical reviews?Recent changes by the Department of Labor to ERISA regulations now require that a disability insurance company provide you an opportunity to respond to adverse information crea... Read More >
What Should a Claimant Expect When Suing Cigna or any Other Disability Company for Long Term Disability Benefits?
ERISA disability lawsuits are complicated due to the pro-insurance company laws. Our disability attorneys have handled thousands of ERISA disability lawsuits and Cigna is one of the companies that we sue on a routine basis. In this video, attorneys Cesar Gavidia and Gregory Dell discuss the fundamentals of a disability lawsuit against Cigna. If you have a potent... Read More >
Are Cigna Short Term Disability Denials on the Rise?
When it comes to claims for short term disability benefits under ERISA governed group policies, more often than not the short term disability policy is not underwritten by an insurance company, but rather it is administered by an insurance company. What this means is when a policy is underwritten by an insurance company the insurance company financially funds the disability benefit to be paid from its own asse... Read More >
Cigna's latest strategies for handling and denying disability benefit claims
Watch Gregory Dell and Stephen Jessup discuss Cigna's latest strategy for handling disability benefit claims. This video has some tips which may help you to secure disability benefits. Any of our lawyers are available for a free initial phone consultation to discuss your claim.... Read More >
Is a Claimant's Complaints of Pain Enough to Qualify for Short or Long Term Disability Insurance Benefits?
The answer to this question applies to the vast majority of long term disability insurance claims that we handle on a daily basis. Pain is subjective. This means that there is no medical device or verifiable method for confirming pain. A claimant's ability to collect disability benefits based upon pain will depend upon the level of documentation and treatment received from treating physicians. In a recent case... Read More >
Is My Insurance Company Allowed to Take An Offset of My Monthly LTD Benefit for Social Security Benefits My Kids Receive As A Result of My Disability?
It is common practice for insurance companies to find ways to limit the amount of money they have to pay to claimants. If you are receiving long-term disability benefits from a policy governed by ERISA, you have most likely been required to also file for Social Security Disability Income benefits. Insurance companies write this requirement into their policies so they can reap the benefits of any past money awa... Read More >
Is My "No-Fault" Auto Insurance Settlement an Offset Under My Long Term Disability Insurance Policy?
If your policy is an employer provided group disability policy governed by ERISA, then any proceeds you receive from a settlement based on "No fault" auto insurance may very well be subject to repayment as "Other Income Benefits." This situation came to light in a recent federal court case in Michigan against Life Insurance Company of America (LINA-more commonly known as Cigna) and serves as a warning to any c... Read More >
Dell Disability Cases
(375)
Showing 8 of 375 Dell Disability Cases
Cigna Sued For Failing To Make A Timely Decision on Appeal
If your disability insurance claim has ever been denied you will have received a formal denial letter from your insurance carrier in which you are advised as to the basis of the denial as well as provided guidelines set forth by ERISA as to the filing of an administrative appeal to challenge the denial of benefits. The most important of these ERISA guidelines is the notification that you have 180 days from the... Read More >
CIGNA Overturns a Waiver of Premium for Group Life Insurance Policy
In early 2019, the widow of a decease man contacted our firm as she was troubled by the actions of CIGNA, also known as Life Insurance Company of North America. Prior to contacting our firm, the lady’s husband had died from metastatic prostate cancer in July of 2018. Through his prior employer, the decedent was covered under two insurance policies: (1) a group long term disability insurance p... Read More >
Cigna Admits Error In Denying Disability Benefits
Our client, a former school teacher, suffering from multiple severe medical conditions including autonomic nervous system damage, small fiber neuropathy, a history of prior back surgery, and severe immune conditions had been receiving long term disability benefits through Cigna for approximately two years under his school system’s group disability policy when he first contacted our office. Like the vast majo... Read More >
CIGNA Overturned Their Denial of LTD Benefits for Nevada Healthcare Coordinator
Our client, Ms. G, formerly worked as a Healthcare Coordinator for a large regional healthcare provider. For many years Ms. G suffered from chronic debilitating effects of multiple physical conditions and ailments, including, among other conditions, Intractable Pain, Chronic Venous Insufficiency, which left her with debilitating physical and cognitive impairments. Ms. G was unwilling to give up her career and ... Read More >
CIGNA Denies Technology Manager under the Own Occupation Provision & Dell Disability Lawyers Wins Appeal
Our client, Mr. N, formerly worked as a Technology Manager / Vice President for a large bank. For many years Mr. N suffered from chronic debilitating effects of multiple physical conditions and ailments, including, among other conditions, Parkinson’s Disease, Parkinson’s Dementia, Dystonia and Bradykinesia, which left him with debilitating physical and cognitive impairments. Mr. N was unwilling to give up ... Read More >
CIGNA overturned previous denial of waiver of life insurance premiums
Our client was the husband and beneficiary of Ms. S, who formerly worked as a registered nurse for a regional Healthcare System. In January 2016 a number of medical issues, including cerebrovascular constriction syndrome, vasomotor headaches, unspecified neurocognitive disorder, chronic fatigue, and chronic pain syndrome forced Ms. S to stop working and submit her claim for disability benefits under her employ... Read More >
Dell Disability Lawyers successfully appeal denial of benefits to claimant with CRPS/RSD
Ms. S contacted our firm after receiving a letter from her disability carrier, Cigna, denying her claim for short term disability benefits under her employer sponsored disability plan. Ms. S was suffering from multiple ailments including a rare, often misunderstood condition called Complex Regional Pain syndrome (CRPS), also known as Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy (RSD). At the start of the claim, Cigna accepted... Read More >
LINA overturned its previous LTD denial for Medical Technologist
Our client, Ms. H, formerly worked as a Medical Technologist for a National Clinical Laboratory. In July 2017 a number of medical issues, including psoriatic arthritis and osteoarthritis forced Ms. H to stop working and submit her claim for disability benefits under her employer’s long-term disability (LTD) policy, which was funded and administered by LINA. Under her employer’s disability policy she would ... Read More >
Disability Lawsuit Stories
(765)
Reviews from Our Clients
