California Court orders CIGNA to disclose amount paid to MES Solutions for medical reviews

CIGNA Insurance Company can run but they can’t hide. Recently, the US District Court for the Central District of California granted Plaintiff Bradley Wojno’s Motion to Compel Defendant CIGNA Insurance to reveal the extent of it financial relationship with MES Solutions. Mr. Wojno’s disability attorney sought information from CIGNA that could unveil potential conflicts and biases of CIGNA’s hired gun doctors relied upon to terminate Mr. Wojno’s disability benefits.

CIGNA argues the information sought by Plaintiff is “wholly irrelevant.”

CIGNA terminated Plaintiff’s disability benefits based largely on testing performed by Dr. Schoenberg who was supplied to CIGNA by MES Solutions (“MES”), a company that supplies medical professionals to insurance companies for claim determinations. In order to determine the potential biases of MES and Dr. Schoenberg, plaintiff sought information on the amount of money paid by CIGNA or its affiliates to MES in the years 2006 through 2010 for medical examinations and medical reviews of claimants. CIGNA argued that the information sought is “wholly irrelevant,” but nonetheless agreed to provide the information pursuant to a protective order limiting access to the information to attorneys only.

Court rules that information sought is relevant to the parties’ claims and defenses.

The court explained that potential conflicts and biases of Dr. Schoenberg, on whom CIGNA relied to terminate the Plaintiff’s disability benefits, are plainly relevant. Furthermore, denying Plaintiff’s requested discovery would deny Plaintiff information that may bear on potential biases of MES and Dr. Schoenberg.

If CIGNA has relied on MES physicians over the years, this fact may indicate that MES, in order to obtain more business from CIGNA, supplies CIGNA with physicians likely to provide claim determinations favorable to CIGNA.

Traditionally, there has been little or no discovery permitted in ERISA cases, as benefit determinations are based on the administrative record.

In reviewing benefits determinations, courts have traditionally allowed little or no discovery in ERISA cases. This is because open-ended discovery would “frustrate a primary goal of ERISA to resolve benefit disputes inexpensively and expeditiously.” However, courts have permitted consideration of evidence outside the administrative record in de novo standard of review-benefit denials. In Welch v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals recognized that discovery aimed at demonstrating a conflict of interest was appropriate.

CIGNA contends that Plaintiff’s discovery is legally irrelevant because discovery typically is done to achieve a shift in the standard of review from abuse of discretion to de novo.

In reviewing ERISA cases, courts typically apply a de novo standard of review or an abuse of discretion standard. When the abuse of discretion standard is used, a court defers to the administrator’s findings and merely decides whether reasonable grounds supported the administrator’s decision. In a de novo review however, a court affords no deference to the administrator’s decision and reviews the claim as if it were for the first time.

CIGNA argued that Plaintiff’s discovery was legally irrelevant because it was not intended to achieve a shift in the standard of review given that CIGNA had already agreed that de novo review was applicable. However, CIGNA’s argument did not consider the Plaintiff’s purpose to determine the potential biases of MES and Dr. Schoenberg based on the amount of money received by MES and the incentive MES may have had in supplying medical professionals likely to be favorable to CIGNA. Furthermore, the court noted that CIGNA failed to cite any case that bars all discovery in de novo cases or to address the potential biases of MES and Dr. Schoenberg.

CIGNA failed to adequately demonstrate why a protective order was necessary.

Because the information sought by the Plaintiff was considered by CIGNA to be “commercially sensitive,” CIGNA pleaded for a protective order to safeguard such information. However, CIGNA failed to convince the court that protective measures were necessary and the court granted Plaintiff’s motion. The court therefore granted Plaintiff’s Motion to Compel without benefit of protective order. We look forward to seeing this information as we believe that CIGNA has paid MES a significant amount of money over the past years.

Comments (3)

  • Brian, thank you for your comment. We have seen hundreds, if not thousands of reviews conducted by doctors hired by MES. There are doctors that make millions of dollars a year doing these exams for insurance companies. In all of our disability insurance claims we look into the background of the hired Gun doctor and how many times they have been hired by the insurance company. Knowing the background of the hired doctor is a great impeachment tool. It’s important to hire a qualified disability insurance attorney and we are available to help claimants nationwide. Thank you for your comment.

    Gregory Dell May 30, 2020  #3

  • A person had published an in house invoice from MES SOLUTIONS to a national insurance company and the figure for one case was $4,000 for the exam to determine a total disability case. A doctor could work one month a year and live well, if they were to consistently say the worker could return to work or go to partial disability. They have “exams” in non-medical office settings, with no sanitation procedures in place. There is no sink, disinfectant, no tissue put over an exam bed for each patient, in a non-medical lab room. The states should not allow these crooks to run these sham exams, but they would not exist without the unscrupulous insurance companies that hire them. Get a lawyer with a proven track record. Your state has a Legal Bar association that oversees the lawyers in your state and can refer someone, then google them online. The “top lawyers” list that is the list of lawyers for your area that are rated by other lawyers in confidence, is a good source. Google it. It is published every year online and lawyers who make the list will make sure it comes up on an internet search. Insurance companies needs to worry that a lawyer can check to see if someone in the insurance company’s office or at MES( or another similar company) doctored the report to change an honest doctor’s report that agrees with your claim. This was a major issue in New York and fraud investigations were set in place. Having a lawyer who will not be paid until you get paid in a settlement, is your safest choice. There should be no upfront costs. Protect yourself as soon as you file a claim with obtaining a lawyer that is aware of the Insurance companies and their henchmen’s tricks.

    Brian May 30, 2020  #2

  • MES Solutions and Cigna should have class action lawsuits brought against them. There are many of us who have had their disability terminated and denial of insurance claims absconded unlawfully. Poll the numbers and find all of us who needed insurance and disability payment to continue to live. These fraudulent companies have caused suffering and death to thousands of people. I am one of them. Congrats on the Cigna/Mes Solutions Court Case! It gives hope to the helpless.

    Jennifer Jordan-Troklus Oct 26, 2014  #1

Leave a comment or ask us a question

Questions About Hiring Us

Do you help Cigna claimants nationwide?

We represent Cigna clients nationwide and we encourage you to contact us for a FREE immediate phone consultation with one of our experienced disability insurance attorneys.

Can you help with a Cigna disability insurance policy?

Our disability insurance lawyers help policy holders seeking short or long term disability insurance benefits from Cigna. We have helped thousands of disability insurance claimants nationwide with monthly disability benefits. With more than 40 years of disability insurance experience we have helped individuals in almost every occupation and we are familiar with the disability income policies offered by Cigna.

How do you help Cigna claimants?

Our lawyers help individuals that have either purchased a Cigna long term disability insurance policy from an insurance company or obtained short or long term disability insurance coverage as a benefit from their employer.

Our experienced lawyers can assist with Cigna:

  • ERISA and Non-ERISA Appeals of Disability Benefit Denials
  • ERISA and Non-ERISA Disability Benefit Lawsuits
  • Applying For Short or Long Term Disability Benefits
  • Daily Handling & Management of Your Disability Claim
  • Disability Insurance Lump-Sum Buyout or Settlement Negotiations

Do you work in my state?

Yes. We are a national disability insurance law firm that is available to represent you regardless of where you live in the United States. We have partner lawyers in every state and we have filed lawsuits in most federal courts nationwide. Our disability lawyers represent disability claimants at all stages of a claim for disability insurance benefits. There is nothing that our lawyers have not seen in the disability insurance world.

What are your fees?

Since we represent disability insurance claimants at different stages of a disability insurance claim we offer a variety of different fee options. We understand that claimants living on disability insurance benefits have a limited source of income; therefore we always try to work with the claimant to make our attorney fees as affordable as possible.

The three available fee options are a contingency fee agreement (no attorney fee or cost unless we make a recovery), hourly fee or fixed flat rate.

In every case we provide each client with a written fee agreement detailing the terms and conditions. We always offer a free initial phone consultation and we appreciate the opportunity to work with you in obtaining payment of your disability insurance benefits.

Do I have to come to your office to work with your law firm?

No. For purposes of efficiency and to reduce expenses for our clients we have found that 99% of our clients prefer to communicate via telephone, e-mail, fax, sessions, or Skype. If you prefer an initial in-person meeting please let us know. A disability company will never require you to come to their office and similarly we are set up so that we handle your entire claim without the need for you to come to our office.

How can I contact you?

When you call us during normal business hours you will immediately speak with a disability attorney. We can be reached at 800-682-8331 or by email. Lawyer and staff must return all client calls same day. Client emails are usually replied to within the same business day and seem to be the preferred and most efficient method of communication for most clients.

Dell & Schaefer Client Reviews   *****

Ravindra P.

I have been a client of Dell & Schaefer for the 6 months and they have already successfully taken my disability claim to approval. It is privilege to write this testimonial. I am a professional myself, a physician and to me these are some of the core strengths of Steve Jessup and his team.

Listening to the client: Attorneys at Dell & Schaefer really listen to you explain your special situation and undoubtedly every one of us has a special circumstance and specific wishes as to what we want. Most of the time attorneys and in general most professionals these days, will listen to you a couple of minutes and then file you away in a category or a bin and chalk out a plan for you in their mind and stop listening to you and start thinking about the next thing that they have to do. That is why these interactions are so often exasperating for the client.

As a physician I used to try and teach medical students that any well trained monkey can read a few books and do a particular thing in a particular situation, it is however extremely essential that you determine what the situation is and no one understands the situation better than your client or patient. I spoke to a couple of attorneys at D&S, initially with someone who took my call and then Steve who was assigned to me and it was impressive that they really tried to get what I was trying to convey, what my special and unique situation was (and whose isn’t?) and what I wanted.

Shock and Awe: At Dell & Schaefer they don’t go in halfway prepared. Their philosophy is to get well prepared and go in guns blazing. They will make you work on your mission until all anticipated difficulties have a contingency plan before even the adversary is intimated of the challenge. I believe it was Sun Tzu who said that the best battles are won before they are fought. Frequently you are a small David pitted against a Goliath adversary with deep pockets and a much larger time horizon. But you do have an advantage, that of time for preparation. The adversary does not know of the battle until you tell them and then the clock starts ticking. At Dell & Schaefer they make full use of your advantage by preparing your case with utmost thoroughness before the engagement.

Art of the possible: Legal action, just like life, is the art of the possible. I have dealt with 5 other attorneys in my career and only one of them apart from Dell & Schaefer understood this. A professional’s job is to tell you what the score is, what possibly can occur in the future and what measures can be taken to favorably change the future. And the last one is possibly the most vital. You don’t want your attorneys telling you all the time why things cannot be done, how laws are stacked against you, how global warming is melting the icecaps, how the oil is running out and how dogs sometimes eat homework assignments. You want them taxing their brains to see what can be done in best manner possible, so the future, which is not yet written, changes favorably for you. Attorneys at D&S get this and consciously incorporate it in their work ethic.

They say that there are four professionals in your life who should also be your friends. Doctor, Lawyer, Accountant and Banker. There is a deeper side to this sound bite that some people get and some don’t. I live at the other end of the country from where Dell & Schaefer work and play, but the world is small and getting smaller and perhaps someday I can add to my stock of friends.

***** 5 stars based on 202 reviews

Speak With An Attorney Now

Request a free legal consultation: Call 800-682-8331 or Email Us