Disability Insurance Lawsuit Stories

Disability denial lawsuit decisions from courts nationwide, reviewed by our attorneys. Learn how policyholders fought back against wrongful claim denials and won.

Showing 141–160 of 766 Lawsuit Stories

Michigan Court Remands Aetna to Reconsider Disability Benefit Denial

A Michigan court finds Aetna's analysis of plaintiff's medical records was flawed in several ways, requiring remand for reconsideration of termination of benefits.

Court Upholds Principal Life's Denial of Extended Disability Benefits

Colorado court agrees with Principal Life that plaintiff's spinal fusion and back pain are no longer disabling based on medical evidence and video surveillance.

Washington Court Finds Liberty Erred in Terminating Disability Benefits

Washington court orders Liberty Life to reinstate long term disability benefits to claimant who is disabled from performing her own occupation due fibromyalgia.

Court Agrees: Principal Life Correctly Terminated Disability Benefits

Florida court upholds Principal Life's termination of benefits when claimant sufficiently recovered from Devic's Syndrome to be able to work in his own or any occupation.

Court Remands Sun Life to Consider Social Security's Decision to Award Plaintiff Disability Benefits

An Illinois court remanded to Sun Life with instructions to consider SSA's award of benefits and, if it disagreed with SSA's decision, to provide reasons why.

Federal Court Orders Principal Life Insurance Company to Pay Disability Benefits

Georgia court rules statute of limitations does not bar ERISA lawsuit and orders Principal Life to pay long term disability to plaintiff who suffers from interstitial cystitis.

Texas Court Orders Union Central to Provide Discovery to Plaintiff

Texas District Court rules against Union Central Life Insurance's motion and grants plaintiff's request for discovery.

Claimant is Ordered to Pay Attorney Fees to Standard for Failing to Exhaust Her Administrative Remedies

Missouri court dismissed ERISA lawsuit when the plaintiff failed to exhaust her administrative remedies. Additionally, plaintiff was ordered to pay Standard attorneys' fees.

Court Orders Aetna to Pay Disability Benefits when Plaintiff was Found Capable of Working

Aetna must pay total disability benefits even though the Illinois plaintiff theoretically can work, but no "reasonable occupation" is available to him.

MetLife Disability Denial Upheld when Claimant Files Lawsuit Without ERISA Appeal

Ohio Appellate court finds MetLife failed to conduct a full and fair review of claimant's degenerative disc pain when it ignored reports of treating physicians.

Court Finds Sedgwick Wrong to Deny Benefits Without Considering Claimant's Actual Job Duties

Oklahoma Court Finds AT&T erred by denying claimant disability benefits without determining if he could perform all the essential functions of his own occupation.

Ohio Court Allows Investigation Into Reliance Standard Conflict of Interest After Disability Denial

An Ohio court granted plaintiff's motion for discovery based on allegations that Reliance Standard Life Insurance Co., had a conflict of interest when denying benefits.

Arkansas Court Reverses Liberty Life's Disability Denial for a Nurse

The court reversed Liberty's disability denial of benefits for a nurse without considering factors concerning her ability to work in its three recommended occupations.

Sappi Company's Difficult Definition of Disability is Not Illegal According to Minnesota Federal Court

Minnesota court upheld Sappi's denial of disability benefits to 30-year employee whose medical records supported her claim that she could no longer do her job.

Washington Court Finds Omaha Wrongfully Relied on Video Surveillance to Deny Disability Benefits

A Washington state court ordered Omaha to pay long term disability benefits to plaintiff when its own video surveillance showed activity consistent with plaintiff's claim.

Can UNUM Be Sued for Defamation in a Disability Insurance Case?

ERISA preempted a defamation claim against Unum when the allegations arose during the course of the Plan's processing of the claim for long term disability benefits.

Massachusetts Court Reverses Liberty Disability Denial for Failure to Examine or Consider Subjective Pain

Massachusetts Court reversed Liberty's denial when it relied on flawed opinions of reviewing physicians and failed to consider the job limitations of claimant’s subjective pain.

Court Sides with PNC: A Claimant Must Provide Proof of How Condition is Disabling

Pennsylvania court upholds PNC Financial Group's denial of long term disability benefits when claimant presented no objective proof her condition was disabling.

Sun Life's Video Surveillance Backfires & is Ordered to Pay Disability Benefits

Federal court awards total disability benefits to plaintiff whose actions shown on Sun Life's video surveillance were consistent with her disability claim of severe back pain.

Court Allows Aetna to Use the Dictionary of Occupational Titles to Deny LTD Benefits

The Maryland District Court upheld Aetna's use of the D.O.T. when determining plaintiff who suffered from chronic hip and neck pain was not disabled from his own occupation.