Broadspire and Aetna deny long-term disability benefits to manager suffering from fibromyalgia, arthritis and cervical disc disease
The case of Mary Midgett v. Washington Group International Long Term Disability Plan, 561 F.3d 887 (8th Cir. 2009) is a reminder that there are discrepancies in how Federal courts apply the law with regard to the weight of credibility to give to an insured’s treating physicians versus the opinions of doctors hired by the insurance carrier to conduct reviews of medical records only.
Mary Midgett was a contract manager for Washington Group International, and was insured under Washington’s group short term and long term disability policies. The policies were originally administered by Broadspire, and then by Aetna. Ms. Midgett filed for benefits under Washington’s short term disability policy due to a myriad of conditions including degenerative arthritis, fibromyalgia and cervical degenerative disc disease, and osteoporosis.
Ms. Midgett treated with various doctors for her conditions. However, as the Court would point to as grounds to uphold the denial of benefits, many of the medical records from her treating physicians were silent as to an opinion on disability, and Ms. Midgett’s primary treating physician’s records suggested he was uncomfortable classifying her as disabled. Based upon results from nerve conduction studies, MRIs, and peer reviews, Aetna denied her claim for short term disability benefits. Ms. Midgett appealed the denial of benefits and added additional medical records from further physicians. Ms. Midgett’s appeal was once again denied, in part upon the review of the medical records from four more insurance company doctors. Between the initial application, and the final determination, Aetna relied upon no less than eight doctors who reviewed the available medical files, and never physically examined Ms. Midgett.
Following Aetna’s denial of benefits, Ms. Midgett filed a lawsuit for the short term disability benefits. The Court, taking into account Ms. Midgett’s medical records from her treating physicians and the opinions of eight insurance company doctors who only reviewed medical records that Ms. Midgett was not totally disabled, the Court sided in favor of the Insurance carrier. In rendering its opinion, the Court pointed to the Supreme Court decision of Black & Decker Disability Plan v. Nord, which stated an insured’s treating physician’s are not automatically entitled to special weight in disability determinations under ERISA. Ultimately the Court determined denial of Ms. Midgett’s short term disability benefits was supported by substantial evidence, as the opinions of all eight of the reviewing physicians accurately represented her medical records and addressed all the evidence supporting her claim for disability.
Comment: Without strong medical support from a claimant’s treat physician(s), it is almost impossible for a claimant to get approved for long-term disability benefits. A claimant must always be aware of the medical records documented by their treating physician and any documentation that the treating physician sends to the disability carrier. The attending physician statements that disability insurance companies send to claimant’s treating doctors contain open ended questions that allow the disability companies to manipulate the answers in support of claim denial. A claimant should always review the attending physician prior to returning the form to the disability carrier.
About the author: Gregory Michael Dell is an attorney and managing partner of the disability income division of Attorneys Dell & Schaefer. Mr. Dell and his team of disability lawyers have assisted thousands of long-term disability claimants with their claims against every major disability insurance company. Attorney Gregory Dell is a nationally recognized disability insurance attorney and the author of a long-term disability insurance law book published by Thomson Reuters, which is a legal reference for attorneys and judges. For a free consultation, please call 800-828-7583 or use our contact page.
Request a Free Consultation
Click here or call 800-682-8331 now!
We respond the same day. We represent disability insurance claimants all over the United States.
Similar / Related:
- Unum approves long-term disability benefits for a general surgeon diagnosed with cervical degenerative disc disease
- Court upholds Hartford’s denial of long-term disability benefits to a quality technical specialist suffering from cervical disc herniations and vertigo
- Former Aetna employee sues Aetna for denial of short-term disability benefits
- Aetna refuses video recording of IME and threatens to deny disability benefits unless claimant agrees to sign IME doctor’s authorization form
- AETNA Life Insurance Company ordered by West Virginia Federal Judge to reevaluate denial of disability benefits to Bristol-Myers Squibb Manager