Ambiguous Disability Policy Language is Construed in Favor of Disability Claimant with Berkshire Life Policy

Most purchasing a disability insurance policy may not negotiate specific language. Rather, insurance companies use stock forms, and the negotiation involves the tradeoff between the extent of coverage and the premium. The insurance company supplies the specific statutory provisions once the extent of coverage is determined. When a dispute arises about specific terms, courts interpreting insurance policies use a time-honored legal principle that construes the language against the drafter. This means that if something in the policy is unclear and susceptible to two or more meanings, the court will favor the interpretation that is most beneficial to the policy holder because the insurance company had the ability to craft the policy in such a manner as to avoid the ambiguity.

Florida Supreme Court Rejects Berkshire Life Insurance Company’s Attempt to Limit Disability Benefits

In Berkshire Life Insurance Company v. Adelberg, the Florida Supreme Court decided when a disability policy fails to define the term “your occupation,” whether the claimant’s “own occupation” is subject to the insurance company’s determination or the claimant’s actual and specific occupation engaged in when the disability occurred. The claimant was employed as a yacht salesman when he injured his knee. He had an own occupation disability policy with Berkshire Life Insurance Company, which defined “total disability” as the “inability to engage in your occupation, … after the first 120 months, the termtotal disability,’ will have this meaning: your inability to engage in any gainful occupation in which you might reasonably be expected to engage, with due regard for your education, training, experience, and prior economic status.” However, the policy did not define the term “your occupation.” Prior to injury, the claimant had worked as a jeweler, food-commodities salesman, and a yacht salesman. Subsequent to injury, he was employed as a freight-space salesman.

In court, the claimant argued his regular occupation when he was injured was that of a yacht salesman, an occupation which required him to walk and crawl though small spaces to inspect the product. Due to his previous and current employment being in sales, Berkshire Life contended his occupation was that of a general salesman and, because he had subsequently been employed in sales, he wasn’t totally disabled within the meaning of the policy and couldn’t recover disability benefits.

The Court held that Berkshire Life failed to define the term “your occupation,” and in doing so, the policy language would lead a reasonable person to conclude that during the first 120 months “your occupation” means the work in which a person is engaged at the time of disability. Therefore, the Court held, “the term ‘your occupation’ refers to the specific work done by the insured at the time of the injury, not work requiring similar skills and producing a comparable income.”

Leave a comment or ask us a question

There are 6 comments

  • Jeff, I am sorry to hear all that you are going through and that Berkshire has delayed in approving your claim. We want to review everything to figure out how we can get this claim approved ASAP. Please feel free to reach out to us at your convenience. A lawyer is always available to speak.

    Alex PalamaraMar 16, 2020  #6

  • How long does it take for them to review my policy that has been in review now for 3 weeks? I got cancer back in July for September I’m sorry now I’m still waiting to get my short-term disability monthly check which is around $900. I’m 3 months behind in my mortgage, my mortgage company will be contacting me soon. I’m now back into a corner not sure what to do, please call. Thank you. My kidney was removed from the cancer, I go back every 4 months to make sure it does not come back but I am unable to return to my job as a chemical applicator with chemicals. I was a termite inspector and applicator. Thank you.

    Jeff H.Mar 16, 2020  #5

  • John,

    I don’t think they would give you a problem while taking the classes. The issue is whether you would be able to do a new job with the information or skills you learn in the classes? The chances of a buyout are very slim and also rare with Guardian.

    Gregory DellSep 18, 2012  #4

  • Hey Greg, thanks for responding.

    My former occupation was as a human resource consultant and my primary responsibility was to hire potential employees into these fortune 500 companies. When I was diagnosed with delayed onset PTSD, my career came crashing down and it all fell apart.

    The classes I’m taking are in real estate and the program is completely online at my own pace through a local community college. Based on this, do you think they’ll come knocking?

    Also, I’ve been on claim for 4 years now. Do you think there is any possibility they may attempt to buy out the remaining portion of the claim? I’m interested, but I heard that Guardian does not buy out claims for conditions such as PTSD and depression. I just want them out of my life understandably…

    Please advise, and thanks again.
    John

    JohnSep 17, 2012  #3

  • John,

    The answer to this question depends on what your occupation was before you became disabled. If the skills required to complete a year of college are similar to the skills necessary to perform your own occupation, then you may be opening up a can of worms. If you are looking into an online program that allows you to work at your own pace, then that would be the best route to take as it is not like a job that requires reasonable continuity of 40 hours a week and 8 hours a day.

    Gregory DellSep 17, 2012  #2

  • Greg, can you go to college while receiving disability benefits?

    I am an Iraq combat vet suffering from PTSD, depression and anxiety. I have an individual, own-occupation policy with Guardian (with no two year limit on mental or nervous disorders) and have been on claim with them since 12/2008. I also receive VA disability (100% rating) and SSDI for the same things.

    Recently, the VA approved a grant for veterans allowing them to go back to school up to a year, and they pay for it. I really want to do this but I don’t want to put myself in a bad position to where they might terminate my benefits.

    Please advise, thanks.

    JohnSep 16, 2012  #1

Speak With An Attorney Now

Request a free legal consultation: Call 800-682-8331 or Email Us