Dentist awarded $1.21 Million for past and future benefits and bad faith damages
Valente v. UnumProvident Corp., Cal., San Francisco County Super. Ct., December 22, 2004
After years of hand pain, Dr. Valente, a dentist with her own practice, underwent hand surgery to remove a painful cyst. Following surgery she suffered bilateral hand pain and could no longer practice dentistry as she did in the past. Eventually, she sold her practice and retired from dentistry.
Dr. Valente was covered by an “own occupation” policy with UNUMProvident, and thus, submitted a claim stating that her hand condition prevented her from practicing dentistry in “a normal and continuous fashion.” The insurance company initially paid the claim, however, benefits were terminated after an in-house physician and two medical examinations concluded that she was not disabled.
Dr. Valente sued the carrier, alleging breach of contract and breach of the covenant of good faith and fair dealing. She alleged that UNUM’s denial of her claim was unreasonable and that she was misled during the course of the investigation. She further alleged that the claim denial was part of a pattern and practice to deny all “own occupation” disability claims because of their high cost to the company.
The insurance company argued that the dentist could not have been disabled because her earnings remained constant throughout the years she said she was in pain and that her retirement was a lifestyle choice.
The jury awarded Dr. Valente a total of $1.21 million, which included over $400,000.00 for the carrier’s breach of good faith and fair dealing.
About the author: Gregory Michael Dell is an attorney and managing partner of the disability income division of Attorneys Dell & Schaefer. Mr. Dell and his team of disability lawyers have assisted thousands of long-term disability claimants with their claims against every major disability insurance company. Attorney Gregory Dell is a nationally recognized disability insurance attorney and the author of a long-term disability insurance law book published by Thomson Reuters, which is a legal reference for attorneys and judges. For a free consultation, please call 800-828-7583 or use our contact page.
Request a Free Consultation
Click here or call 800-682-8331 now!
We respond the same day. We represent disability insurance claimants all over the United States.
Similar / Related:
- Podiatrist sues Northwestern Mutual seeking disability insurance benefits and bad faith damages
- Prudential Insurance Company breaches disability contract and jury awards claimant $15.2 million in damages
- Dentist sues disability insurance carrier, third party administrator and allegedly independent medical examiner as a result of their conspiracy and bad faith actions to wrongfully deny disability benefits
- Unum’s claim handling exposes them to a multi-million dollar bad faith disability lawsuit
- Pennsylvania Federal Court denies Unum’s attempts to dismiss a physician’s bad faith disability lawsuit
Search Disability Cases & News